Grandma’s Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie Recipe: A Family Tradition

Among these cherished culinary treasures is Grandma’s Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie Recipe, a traditional dessert whose rich flavors and velvety texture have been savored across our family table for generations.

This pie isn’t just a treat; it’s a slice of history, lovingly perfected over time, its recipe card worn and stained from years of use.

Today, you’re in for more than just a list of ingredients and instructions. In this article, you’ll uncover the storied past of sweet potato pie and why it’s such an integral part of Southern cuisine. With every step, from selecting the perfect sweet potatoes to mastering the flaky crust, you’ll gain invaluable insights to ensure that Grandma’s pie graces your table just as it has ours — exuding warmth, love, and the unmatchable satisfaction that comes from a dessert made right.

Ready your kitchen and your heart as we dive into Grandma’s Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie Recipe through my family recipe blog.

Whether you’re continuing a tradition or starting a new one, let’s make sure that every bite tells the story of where this pie comes from and why it remains so special to those who gather around to enjoy it.

The History and Significance of Sweet Potato Pie

The sweet potato pie is more than just a dessert; it’s a symbol of unity, resilience, and cultural heritage. Its origins trace back to the era of slavery in America when African slaves transformed the sweet potato – a crop introduced by European colonizers – into an enduring culinary tradition.

This humble root vegetable was readily accessible and highly nourishing, making it a cornerstone of Southern cuisine. Over time, the transformation of this nutrient-rich tuber into a rich, flavorful pie became an act of creativity and survival, ingrained in soul food traditions.

A Culinary Journey

From Staple Crop to Sweet Delight

During slavery, African slaves relied on meager rations provided by their captors. However, they ingeniously turned these rations into dishes that would sustain them physically and spiritually. The sweet potato, being one such staple crop, became the basis for creating something extraordinary – the sweet potato pie.

Preserving Heritage Through Food

The art of making sweet potato pie was passed down from generation to generation, serving as a link to ancestral roots and preserving cultural heritage. With each bite of this delectable dessert, African Americans found solace in their shared history and connection with their ancestors.

The Essence of Sweet Potato Pie: Love, Family, and Tradition

What makes the old-fashioned sweet potato pie recipe truly special is its deep connection to family and community. Grandma’s version carries decades of love, nostalgia, and culinary wisdom. Each ingredient is carefully chosen; every step is performed with precision and patience.

“As the sweet aroma fills the house, it brings back cherished memories of family gatherings, laughter echoing around the dining table, and grandma’s comforting presence.”

excerpt from “Sweet Potato Pie” by Dominique Christina

In essence, Grandma’s Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie Recipe is not just about creating an iconic dessert. It’s about embracing our roots and celebrating our cultural heritage while savoring each bite as a reminder of home.

The Timeless Appeal of Sweet Potato Pie: Simplicity and Tradition

This beloved dessert has stood the test of time because it represents authenticity in its purest form. It showcases simple ingredients transformed through love and traditional cooking techniques into a comforting treat that soothes the soul.

From the heartwarming filling to the flaky crust, every aspect of this pie is reminiscent of Southern hospitality at its best. The warmth that emanates from each slice is not only due to its velvety texture or caramelized sweetness but also because it carries with it an element of shared history and familial love.

Crafting Your Own Piece of History: The Family Recipe Lives On

The journey from humble roots to delectable dessert speaks volumes about its cultural significance – as does your anticipation for what lies ahead: crafting your own version of your family’s cherished Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie.

Key Ingredients for Authentic Flavor

Sweet Potatoes: The Heart of the Pie

When you think of Grandma’s Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie, the first thing that comes to mind is undoubtedly the sweet potatoes themselves. This traditional recipe relies on the natural sweetness and creamy texture of fresh sweet potatoes, transforming them into a smooth and irresistible filling.

Why Are Sweet Potatoes Essential?

Sweet potatoes are not just a staple ingredient; they are the soul of the pie. Here’s why:

  • Flavor: Sweet potatoes bring a unique, earthy sweetness that is unmatched by any other ingredient. Their natural sugars caramelize in the baking process, deepening the flavor profile.
  • Texture: Upon baking, sweet potatoes provide a velvety consistency that becomes the foundation of your pie’s filling.
  • Nutrition: Rich in vitamins, fiber, and antioxidants, sweet potatoes add a nutritious boost to this indulgent dessert.

Selecting the Best Sweet Potatoes

To ensure your pie lives up to its full potential, use these tips when selecting your sweet potatoes:

  • Color: Look for vibrant orange-hued sweet potatoes, which typically have a higher sugar content and creamier texture.
  • Firmness: Choose sweet potatoes that feel firm to the touch with no soft spots or signs of sprouting.
  • Size: Opt for medium-sized sweet potatoes that will cook evenly and are easier to manage when preparing your filling.

Preparing Your Sweet Potatoes

The method you choose for cooking sweet potatoes can greatly influence their taste and texture. Consider these two popular methods:


  • Roasting enhances their natural sweetness and allows for a deeper caramelization.
  • Cut your sweet potatoes into uniform pieces, coat lightly with oil, and roast until tender — this typically takes about 30 minutes at 425°F (220°C).
  • Once cooled, the skins will peel off easily, and you can mash them smoothly without any fibrous strings.


  • Boiling is a quicker method but can introduce excess moisture to your pie filling if not done correctly.
  • Peel and cut your sweet potatoes into even chunks before boiling to ensure consistent cooking.
  • Boil until fork-tender — usually around 20 minutes — then drain thoroughly to remove as much water as possible before mashing.

Each preparation method offers its own nuances to the final product. Roasting will likely give you a richer flavor due to caramelization while boiling offers convenience and speed. Ultimately, personal preference should guide your choice.

2. Butter, Sugar, and Other Flavor Enhancers

In the journey of creating Grandma’s Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie, sweet potatoes undoubtedly play the leading role. Yet, supporting characters like butter, sugar, and other flavor enhancers cannot be underestimated as they work behind the scenes to elevate the pie’s taste to new heights.

The Role of Butter

Butter is more than just a fat source in this traditional recipe. It imparts a richness that complements the earthy sweetness of fresh sweet potatoes. When melted, it bonds with other ingredients, harmoniously blending flavors while aiding in achieving that desired luscious consistency in the filling.

The Sweetness of Sugar

Moving onto sugar, it sweetens the pie filling but also lends subtle complexity. Dark brown sugar, in particular, boasts of deep caramel undertones that accentuate the natural sweetness of sweet potatoes. Its molasses content contributes to a richer color and moist texture.

The Magic of Warm Spices

The unique flavor profile of this beloved dessert would not be complete without warm spices. A blend of nutmeg, cinnamon, and ginger creates an evocative bouquet that reminds one of cozy family gatherings around the fireplace. For maximum aromatic impact, freshly grated nutmeg is recommended.

The Subtle Power of Vanilla Extract

Finally, vanilla extract enters the scene as a stealthy flavor enhancer. It may seem insignificant amidst these robust ingredients but its presence balances out the flavors beautifully. The delicate floral notes of vanilla extract add depth and soften the assertive spice blend.

All these elements — buttery richness, caramel sweetness, warm spices, and a hint of vanilla — unite to capture the true essence of Grandma’s Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie. Their roles might be understated but their contribution to the overall taste experience is undeniable.

3. Binding Agents: Eggs and Evaporated Milk

In the symphony of ingredients that make up Grandma’s Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie, every part plays a crucial role. After the sweet potatoes, butter, and sugar have done their part, it’s time for the binding agents to step in – eggs and evaporated milk.

The Role of Eggs in the Pie

Eggs are more than just a mere ingredient; they are the backbone of this traditional recipe. They provide structure to the pie, ensuring that your filling sets solidly rather than oozing out when you slice into it. Moreover, eggs contribute to the rich texture of the pie, giving it that custard-like mouthfeel that makes each bite a delight.

The Magic of Evaporated Milk

However, eggs alone cannot do the job. They need a helping hand from evaporated milk. This condensed form of milk lends creaminess and richness to our beloved pie. The subtle sweetness complements the fresh sweet potatoes perfectly, and its thick consistency helps achieve that luscious velvety texture we all crave in a perfect sweet potato pie.

Substituting Ingredients for Dietary Needs

Understanding that dietary restrictions or preferences may pose a challenge for some, there are viable substitutions available:

  • Flax eggs: A blend of ground flaxseed and water can mimic the binding properties of eggs for those following vegan or egg-free diets.
  • Coconut milk: For those avoiding dairy or looking for an extra hint of flavor, canned coconut milk can be a delicious substitute for evaporated milk.

Remember that while substitutions can work well, they might slightly alter the final taste and texture. So if you’re after authentic Grandma’s Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie experience, sticking with eggs and evaporated milk is advisable.

Now let’s move on to the next section where we’ll dive into the step-by-step process of making this delightful pie from scratch.

Grandma’s Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie Recipe

Grandma’s Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie Recipe – Ingredient List

1. Crafting the Homemade Pie Crust

Homemade pie crust is the unsung hero of any great sweet potato pie. Achieving that perfect tender flake and buttery crust might seem daunting, but with these straightforward instructions, you’ll be on your way to a crust that rivals Grandma’s.

Choosing Your Ingredients

  • Cold butter is crucial. It’s the little pockets of butter that create steam during baking, which in turn gives the crust its flakiness.
  • Use plain all-purpose flour for a consistent result.
  • A pinch of salt enhances the flavor of the crust.
  • Ice water helps to bind the dough without activating gluten too much, which can make the dough tough.

The Process

  1. Measure Precisely: Start by sifting your flour into a large bowl. Measure your ingredients carefully to ensure consistency every time you bake.
  2. Cutting in Butter: Using a pastry cutter or your fingers, work quickly to cut cold, cubed butter into the flour until you have a mixture resembling coarse crumbs.
  3. Adding Water: Drizzle ice-cold water over the flour-butter mixture, using just enough to bring it together into a dough. Handle as little as possible to avoid warming the butter.
  4. Forming The Dough: Gently shape your dough into a disc and wrap it in plastic wrap. Avoid over-kneading; you should still see streaks of butter in the dough.
  5. Chilling is Key: Refrigerate your dough for at least one hour before rolling it out. This step allows the gluten to relax and ensures that your dough won’t shrink back when you start rolling.
  6. Rolling Out: On a lightly floured surface, roll out your chilled dough from the center outward, rotating frequently to prevent sticking and to maintain an even thickness.
  7. Into The Pan: Carefully place your rolled-out dough into your pie dish. Tuck it in without stretching and trim any excess from around the edges.
  8. Crimping Edges: For a decorative touch, crimp the edges using your fingers or a fork for that classic homemade look.

Blind Baking: Why and How

Blind baking ensures that your homemade pie crust won’t become soggy once filled with the sweet potato mixture. Here’s how you do it:

  1. Preheat your oven to 375°F (190°C).
  2. Line your crust with parchment paper and fill with pie weights or dried beans/rice to keep it flat against the pan and prevent bubbling up.
  3. Bake for about 15 minutes until edges are just starting to turn golden.
  4. Remove pie weights and parchment paper and bake for another 5 minutes so that the bottom starts to cook through.

Tips for Success

  • Keep everything cold – if at any point during preparation you find the butter is melting or dough getting sticky, pop it back in the fridge.
  • Don’t skip chilling after rolling out – this helps prevent shrinking.
  • Patch any tears with excess dough – there’s no need for perfection when patching; it adds character!

2. The Delicious Filling: From Potatoes to Pie

Making the smooth and sweet potato filling is like creating a work of art. This part will show you how to do it, starting from cooking and mashing the potatoes to adding flavors like brown butter.

Choosing the Right Sweet Potatoes

To make sure your pie turns out great, pick sweet potatoes that are firm and have no marks or cuts on them. These things can affect how good your pie will taste. Remember, these root vegetables are the heart of your sweet potato pie recipe.

Cooking the Sweet Potatoes

  1. Start by washing and peeling your sweet potatoes.
  2. Cut them into pieces that are all the same size, so they cook evenly.
  3. You want them to be soft but not too mushy.

Mashing the Potatoes

  1. After they’re cooked, drain the water and put them in a big bowl.
  2. Use a fork or a special tool called a potato masher to smash them until they’re smooth with no lumps.

Adding Flavor with Brown Butter

  1. Get ready to make some magic happen with your mashed sweet potatoes!
  2. Melt some butter in a pan until it turns golden brown and smells nutty – this is called brown butter.
  3. While it’s still hot, pour this special butter over your mashed sweet potatoes.

Tip: Brown butter adds a rich and nutty taste to your filling.

Enhancing Sweetness and Flavor

  • For sweetness, add granulated sugar and a bit of salt.
  • The sugar makes the potatoes even sweeter without making it too much.
  • Salt helps balance out the sweetness and brings out all the flavors.

Tip: You can also use warm spices like cinnamon, nutmeg, or ginger for an extra kick of flavor!

Making It Extra Special (Optional)

If you want to make your pie more exciting, here are some ideas:

  • Adding a splash of bourbon or rum for a grown-up twist.
  • Using other warm spices like cinnamon, nutmeg, or ginger.
  • Mixing in some vanilla extract for a hint of sweetness.

Remember, our goal here is simplicity – simple directions lead to perfect results every time. So don’t worry if you’re not an expert at baking; you can still make this homemade pie crust and filling without any problems.

Soon enough, we’ll be pouring this amazing filling into our already baked, flaky, and buttery crust.

3. Baking to Perfection

Achieving the perfect bake for Grandma’s Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie is less about secret techniques and more about following some straightforward instructions. Whether it’s a festive holiday gathering or a cozy family dinner, this buttery crust filled with rich, custard filling will be the highlight.

Preparing to Bake

When you’re ready to bake, here’s what you need to do:

  1. Preheat Your Oven: Set your oven to 350°F (175°C). This temperature allows the filling to cook through evenly without burning the edges of your homemade pie crust.
  2. Position the Rack: Make sure the baking rack is in the middle of the oven. This ensures that heat is distributed evenly.

Baking Instructions

Once everything is set, it’s time to start baking! Here’s a step-by-step guide:

  1. Pre-Bake the Crust: If you’re using a homemade pie crust, pre-baking (or blind baking) is essential. This step prevents it from becoming soggy once the filling is added.
  • Line your crust with parchment paper.
  • Fill it with pie weights or dried beans.
  • Bake for about 10 minutes.
  1. Fill ‘er Up: After pre-baking, remove the crust from the oven and take out the weights and parchment paper. Pour in your sweet potato filling until it’s just below the rim of the crust.
  2. Time to Bake: Slide your pie into the preheated oven and bake for 50-60 minutes.
  3. Check for Doneness: To check if your pie is done, insert a knife near the center. If it comes out mostly clean, your pie is ready!
  4. Cool Down: Let your sweet potato pie cool on a wire rack for at least 2 hours. This helps it solidify and hold its shape.

Tips for a Perfect Bake

Here are some helpful tips to ensure your pie turns out amazing:

  • If you notice the edges of your crust browning too quickly, wrap them in foil or use a pie shield.
  • A glass or ceramic pie dish can provide more consistent heat distribution for an even bake.

Remember, ovens may vary, so keep an eye on your pie as it bakes. The goal is a custard that’s set with a lightly golden top — a tempting invitation to slice and enjoy.

This homemade pie crust filled with grandma’s signature sweet potato mixture makes any occasion special. With these tips and visual cues, you can confidently approach baking as an enjoyable part of creating memories around delicious food with loved ones.

Serving Up Warmth and Nostalgia

Sweet potato pie isn’t just a dessert; it’s a vessel of comfort, carrying with it the warmth of memories and the sweetness of tradition. When you slice into Grandma’s Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie, you’re not only indulging in a holiday dessert but also in the legacy of countless family gatherings that have come before. Each piece is an invitation to savor, to reminisce, and to create new moments.

Ways to Serve Grandma’s Sweet Potato Pie:

  • Classic Simplicity: Sometimes, the pie itself is all you need. The rich flavors and velvety texture can stand proudly on their own.
  • With Whipped Cream: A generous dollop of whipped cream adds a cloud-like contrast to the dense filling, creating a balance that dances on the palate.
  • Ice Cream Pairing: For those who love a cold touch to their warm pie, a scoop of cinnamon ice cream complements the pie’s spices perfectly.
  • Seasonal Garnishes: Consider topping your slice with toasted pecans or a drizzle of maple syrup for an extra festive touch.

In our family, no Thanksgiving was complete without this pie gracing the table. I recall one year when my cousin attempted to “reinvent” the classic by serving it with homemade cardamom whipped cream. Skeptical at first, we were quickly won over by how well the exotic spice played with the sweet potatoes’ earthiness. It became another cherished memory, another layer added to our pie’s story.

This pie has been more than just a recipe; it has been a witness to laughter-filled kitchens, to gentle teasing over who got the biggest slice, and to silent nods of appreciation between bites. It stood as an unspoken symbol of love when words were scarce but emotions abundant.

As you carry on with this sweet potato pie tradition, you invite these same sentiments into your home. Whether topped with whipped cream or paired with ice cream, each serving is an opportunity to connect—with the past, with loved ones, and with the simple joy that good food brings.

Putting a Personal Spin on Tradition

While staying true to the roots of Grandma’s Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie, there’s room for you to add your personal touch. This timeless recipe can be elevated with creative variations that not only enhance its taste but also the overall experience of baking and savoring it.

Adding Spirit to the Filling

Flavor additions can be as simple as infusing bourbon into the sweet potato filling. The smoky, caramel notes of bourbon complement the natural sweetness of the potatoes, adding depth and complexity. If you choose this route, make sure to carefully mix it in after mashing the potatoes, ensuring an even distribution throughout the filling.

A Drizzle of Sweetness

Another option is drizzling molasses over the freshly baked pie. Its rich, dark sweetness enhances contrast with the creamy custard filling. When using molasses, remember that a little goes a long way—too much can overwhelm the other flavors.

Crunchy Topping

Introducing texture contrast can also elevate your pie experience. Consider sprinkling toasted pecans or walnuts on top before serving. The crunchiness of the toasted nuts adds an unexpected and delightful contrast to each bite.

As you experiment with these suggestions, remember:

“The essence of cooking is about creating something delicious that brings joy to those who consume it.”

Feel free to explore other potential variations that align with your personal preferences or dietary needs. It could be as simple as swapping in a gluten-free crust or incorporating vegan-friendly ingredients.

In crafting your version of Grandma’s Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie, you’ll find that it’s more than just a dessert—it’s a culinary canvas for expressing creativity and sharing love through food. Each tweak or twist you introduce becomes part of your unique story, adding another layer to an already cherished family tradition.

Tips for Success and Storage

Grandma’s Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie is not just a delectable treat but also a budget-friendly dessert perfect for any occasion. As you embark on this culinary journey, here are some additional tips to help you achieve a perfect slice every time.

Preheating the Oven

A crucial yet often overlooked step is preheating the oven sufficiently. Your oven needs to reach the exact temperature required for baking. This ensures an even and consistent cooking process, giving your pie that ideal flaky crust and velvety filling. A well-preheated oven is the secret to transforming your ingredients into a delightful dessert.

Cooling Time

Resist the temptation to immediately dig into your freshly baked pie. Allowing it to cool properly is vital for achieving the desired texture and flavor profile. The cooling process helps the filling set completely and the flavors meld together, enhancing the overall taste of your pie.

Storing Leftovers

The taste of Grandma’s Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie can be savored over time if stored properly. Here’s how:

  • Short-term storage: After your pie cools completely, loosely cover it with aluminum foil or plastic wrap and store at room temperature. It should last about 2-3 days.
  • Long-term storage: For a longer shelf life, place the cooled pie in a freezer-safe bag or container and freeze it. It can last up to 3-4 months in the freezer. When ready to eat, thaw it in the refrigerator overnight and warm slightly before serving.

Remember that proper storage not only ensures your pie stays fresh but also keeps its authentic flavor intact.

Mastering Grandma’s Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie involves following this beloved recipe closely while also taking care of these little details. By doing so, you’ll not only honor tradition but also create a delightful dessert that’s sure to impress.

Embrace a Sweet Legacy with Grandma’s Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie Recipe

Grandma’s Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie Recipe is much more than just a dessert; it’s a rich tapestry of memories and shared experiences. This family tradition is steeped in the love and care that can only be found in a recipe passed from one generation to the next. Here’s why you should embrace this legacy:

1. Preserving Family Heritage

Each time you measure the sugar, blend the spices, and roll out the crust, you’re honoring the past and contributing to your family’s future.

2. Creating Memories

As you share this sweet potato pie with loved ones, you’re crafting new memories that will be cherished for years to come.

3. Passing Down Skills

Baking from scratch is a valuable skill. Teaching younger family members how to bake this pie ensures these culinary traditions are not lost.

Remember, every slice of Grandma’s Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie is an opportunity to connect with your roots and keep the spirit of family gatherings alive. So, preheat your oven, tie on your apron, and get ready to create more than just a dessert—you’re making history one pie at a time.

Continue Reading

1 thought on “Grandma’s Old Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie Recipe: A Family Tradition”

Leave a Comment